The Lincoln thimble is made from cedarwood. The other one is either wood or fiberglass, I'm not sure which.
The Lincoln's Birthplace one is about 1 1/8" tall and 1" in diameter, and the opening is about 1/2".
The hand painted one has tiny pink designs.
It measures about 1" tall and 15/16" in diameter, and has a 5/8 diameter opening.
Check photos and ask any questions.